When You Should Fix Instead of Redesign Your Coaching Website
The problem: endless tweaking, or clueless about changes, or spending forever revamping with still no results.
Hereโs what often happens. I meet coaches who are struggling to grow their business, get things launched, or rethink their marketing focus. They want to revitalize what theyโre doing and gain some traction.
When I hear them out, I usually get a lot of low-level questions. Theyโre stuck on their logo or wording, or have old material they want to keep and donโt know where to put it.
Theyโre looking at their website and wondering: should I fix it or redesign?
A redesign can leave you just as stuck because …
A redesign takes time, money, and energy. You can spend weeks on the logo, wording, and where everything goes while the bigger questionโhow youโre going to get out there and grow your businessโremains unanswered.
Meanwhile, the business still needs clients. The people you could reconnect with, the referral sources you could contact, the talks you could giveโall of that can get pushed back while you get the website ready.
Then the new site goes live. It looks better, but youโre still wondering how to get people to it and turn that attention into coaching conversations. Youโve finished a website project without getting much closer to the business you wanted.
Your website needs something to support. It might help you grow a newsletter or share online content. Or itโs an important piece of credibility as you build your social profiles, network, or give talks. Without some clarity about what comes next, itโs hard to decide what the website needs.
The key is to “find your B” to answer, Fix or redo?
When a coach asks whether to fix or redesign their website, I like to figure out their B: their next big step on their little business adventure. To be more specific โฆ
- Point A is where youโre at right now.
- Point B is the next major effort to grow your biz.
- Point Z is the next mountain top (your goal like say 10 ongoing clients).
All of the other letters are steps, surprises, discoveries, successes and โlearning opportunitiesโ along the way ๐

โBโ is a game plan or a strategy. We should look projects to do once the website is up. It could be as simple as telling everyone what you do, reconnecting with potential referral sources, and posting content in your networks on a regular basis. Each coachโs situation varies.
To figure out B, I like asking A LOT OF questions. Here are a few faves โฆ
- Whatโs worked in the past? What hasnโt?
- What networks, resources, connections, or other assets can we leverage?
- Whatโs been in the way of you getting out there?
If I sense headgames are in the way (fears, worries, resistances, beliefs), I like digging with, โWhat else can we throw on the table? Whatโs not being said?โ
A good talk, close look, and honest look often directs us to a solid โBโ and then itโs easier to figure out what we should do with the website to support the plan.
Some good reasons to FIX and not revamp, even if your gut says redo it all.
Some common reasons we should tweak, tug, and tighten instead of overhaul.
- Youโve got a lot of traffic
- Youโve got good search rankings
- Youโve got established backlinks bringing you eyeballs (e.g. directory, ICF chapter websites, profiles)
- Youโve got a big website and some of it is useful
- Youโve had some success with it, so we can investigate (stats help).
Sometimes a few fixes are all you need to support that next step. Thereโs no reason to redesign everything if the website can already help you get where youโre going.
